home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQS);faqs.214
-
-
-
- Some banks will waive the annual fee if you tell them that you'll go
- elsewhere if you have to pay it. Others will not. You may want to
- ask (politely) to talk to a supervisor, since the front-line person
- may not care whether you cancel your card and may not have the
- authority to make concessions. Don't bluff on this unless you are
- confident you can get a card elsewhere.
-
- One article in Usenet reported that the author called Citibank to
- cancel his Visa card because of the annual fee. They would not
- waive the fee but said they would send him a gift certificate for
- the same amount if he kept his card.
-
- Q205. What about application fees?
-
- These are extremely uncommon. Though such fees are legal, look long
- and hard at the terms before you agree to pay an application fee,
- even if you are "guaranteed" acceptance. You can almost certainly
- do better elsewhere. (See the "900" numbers later in this section.)
-
- Q206. What other fees should I be concerned about?
-
- Many cards assess an "over-limit fee" if you charge something that
- takes you over your credit limit. They may or may not allow the
- charge if they assess this fee. $5-$10 is common.
-
- Some cards charge a late payment fee in addition to the finance
- charges. Again, $5-$10 is common.
-
- Some cards charge a transaction fee for cash advances. This may be
- a flat amount (around $2), a percentage (1%-2% is common), or a
- combination. These fees are in addition to the stated interest
- rate, which usually starts accruing as soon as you get the money.
-
- You have the right under the law to know what all these fees are
- when you apply.
-
- Q207. Why is a grace period important?
-
- The grace period is the time after the billing date that you have to
- pay off the bill without paying finance charge. (Grace periods for
- cash advances are pretty rare, since the bank would lose money on
- them.) T&E cards typically have generous grace periods; bank cards
- usually have 25 days but a few have 30 and many have no grace
- period. In every case the grace period runs from the date printed
- on the bill, not from the date you get the bill.
-
- For instance, suppose your bill is prepared on the 28th of every
- month and the grace period is 25 days. If you make a purchase on
- July 3 it will show up on the July 28 bill and you'll have until
- August 22 (July 28 plus 25 days) to pay it off for free. If you
- don't pay the full balance, your August bill will show a finance
- charge, and so will every bill after that until you pay off your
- full balance.
-
- Some banks give you a grace period only in months when your previous
- balance is zero. Others (fewer of them all the time) give the
- stated grace period on all new purchases even if you have a balance
- from last month. The second method can save you big bucks; be sure
- to find out how your bank does it when you apply for the card.
-
- Q208. Why is a discount better than a rebate?
-
- Rebates are a percentage refund on your purchases, either by check
- or by credit to your account. Discounts actually reduce the price
- on the bill before you pay it. Discover offers rebates on all
- purchases. The Ameritech Complete MasterCard gives 10% rebates on
- credit-card calls at the end of the year, where the AT&T Universal
- card gives 10% discounts on credit-card calls. On the principle
- that it's always better to keep money in your account than to pay it
- out and get some of it back later, discounts are better than rebates
- if the numbers are otherwise equal.
-
- Q209. What else should I watch out for in cards with rebates?
-
- First, when will the rebate be issued, at the end of the month or at
- the end of the year? (Typically, it's after the end of the year.)
-
- Second, how is the rebate calculated? Be sure to read the fine
- print. For example, Discover advertises "up to 1%" rebate. That's
- true; but the fine print shows that you get back 1% of every dollar
- you charge after $3000 a year; the first $3000 is rebated at rates
- between a quarter and three quarters of a percent. (Confirmed by
- telephone, 1991 Oct 14, and by personal experience.)
-
- Q210. How do I evaluate a secured card?
-
- Use the same criteria as for any other card. Ask the bank some
- additional questions: What interest is paid on the deposit? If I
- maintain a good credit record, when could I be considered for an
- unsecured card?
-
- Also ask yourself if you might conceivably have need for the
- deposited funds during the required term. If so, find out up front
- whether you can withdraw the deposit in case of financial emergency,
- and what it costs in interest and penalties to do that.
-
- You will want a secured card if you don't qualify for an unsecured
- one but you need credit.
-
- You may want a secured card even if you could get an unsecured card.
- Why? Since a secured card represents less risk to the bank,
- interest rates may be lower than for unsecured cards. (Two recent
- surveys showed an Illinois bank's secured card with a grace period
- and no annual fee that had the lowest interest rate in the surveys.)
-
- Q211. Shouldn't I get as many cards as I can?
-
- Not necessarily. The more cards you have, the fatter your wallet is
- and the more cards you have to keep track of.
-
- See section 7, "Credit bureaus and your credit rating," in part 3 of
- this list, for other reasons why having a lot of cards can be a
- problem.
-
- Q212. Why would I want more than one of the same kind of card?
-
- Some people like having, say, two MasterCards or two Visas. I don't
- see the advantages of such an arrangement. I've heard some people
- say they charge a big-ticket item on one card and pay it off a
- little bit every month, while charging normal purchases to the other
- card and paying them off in full every month. However, credit-card
- debt is about the most expensive way there is to finance a big item;
- you're almost certainly better off getting a loan from your bank or
- credit union.
-
- You might want to have a MasterCard and a Visa, or a bank card and a
- T&E card, to be able to charge at places that take one but not the
- other. In this case, try to schedule the billing dates two weeks
- apart. (Some card issuers will alter your billing date if you ask.)
-
- Q213. Is a gold card worth the higher annual fee?
-
- Gold cards typically carry some of these perks: collision damage
- waiver on auto rentals, travel insurance, extended warranty on
- purchases, roadside assistance, higher credit limits, frequent-flyer
- miles, and of course :-) prestige.
-
- Many non-gold cards also offer some or all of these. The AAA offers
- roadside assistance. Many standard auto insurance policies cover
- the CDW on rentals. If you have a good record on your existing
- card, you can probably get your credit limit increased by calling
- the issuer. There's no one answer to whether these cards are worth
- the extra money: you have to decide what the perks and prestige are
- worth to you, and your neighbor could well come up with a different
- answer.
-
- Q214. I was mailed a solicitation for a Visa or MasterCard that accrues
- frequent-flyer miles on my purchases. Is this a good thing?
-
- It may or may not be. Does the airline fly to places you really
- want to go? How many dollars must you charge to earn a free ticket?
- Is the airline likely to be around by then? Are you likely to spend
- more than you otherwise would, just to accumulate the miles?
-
- Ask yourself questions like these, in addition to all the others
- mentioned in this section.
-
- Q215. I belong to the Benevolent Order of Mumble, and they mailed me a
- credit-card solicitation. It would be a MasterCard with their
- logo on it. Is this a good deal?
-
- This is an affinity card; see section 1, "Credit cards, other
- cards." Evaluate an affinity card as you would any other. If you
- would consider it a good deal in the open market, based on the way
- you use credit, then it's a good deal. But an expensive card
- doesn't become a good deal just because a small fraction of the
- profits are turned back to your organization. Unless the card is a
- good deal for you personally, it's a better idea to make a direct
- donation to your organization -- and you get a tax deduction too, if
- it's a charity.
-
- 216. My bank offered me a deal if I would agree to set up my checking
- account for automatic withdrawal on the due date to pay the credit
- card. Is this a good idea?
-
- It depends on the specific terms of the deal. For example, a
- reduced interest rate is meaningless if you pay off every month
- anyway.
-
- It also depends on your own spending patterns. If you tend to
- forget to pay your bills on time, this arrangement can save you some
- late charges or finance charges. On the other hand, if you forget
- to enter the automatic withdrawal in your checkbook you may find
- you're overdrawn and start bouncing checks.
-
- Some consumers have reported problems with disputed charges being
- paid automatically, or the bank disregarding special requests to
- alter a scheduled payment. You should weigh carefully this
- additional loss of control over your checking account against the
- benefits promised.
-
- Q217. I got a call (or saw an ad) inviting me to call a 900 number for a
- "guaranteed" MasterCard or Visa. Is this a good deal?
-
- No. These offers require you to pay up front either for a specific
- secured card or (worse) for a list of banks that issue secured
- cards.
-
- Instead, if you need a secured card, apply to a bank that advertises
- them. (Citibank in New York started a nationwide program of secured
- cards in late summer 1991.)
-
- Even better, ask your own bank about getting a secured card there,
- or referring you. There's no charge for making the inquiry, and I
- have never heard of a bank charging a fee for a direct application.
-
- Finally, check the published lists (see section 3, "Lists of good
- cards"), and apply directly to banks listed there.
-
- Q218. What should I watch out for in a corporate card?
-
- A "corporate card" is an ordinary card, typically American Express
- or Diners Club. However, you don't apply for it. It is issued to
- certain employees of a company for the company's convenience in
- managing travel expenses. There are a couple of possible problems.
-
- First, you may be individually responsible for charges to the card,
- even though you use it only for business purposes. This can be a
- problem if your company is very slow to reimburse you for expenses.
-
- Second, some cardholders have posted articles to the effect that
- corporate cards may not have the same buyer protections (like
- extended warranty) that personal cards do.
-
- Q219. I saw an ad for a card I've never heard of. What's the story?
-
- Be careful when applying for credit. Some companies advertise
- credit cards on TV. The problem is that although the card looks a
- lot like a Visa or MasterCard, it is only good for merchandise from
- the company's own catalog. Despite the promise of "discount
- prices," you will pay more than you would pay in stores or through
- other mail-order channels.
-
- Most legitimate catalog companies take Visa, MasterCard, American
- Express, or some combination. You should always pick merchandise
- for its own qualities, not because you're forced into it by which
- credit card you have.
-
- Q220. I got an application for a card that didn't state interest rate
- and fees. Is this legal?
-
- No. The U.S. Fair Credit and Charge Card Disclosure Act requires
- issuers of charge or credit cards (including retail stores) to
- reveal certain basic information in tabular form with the applica-
- tion or the "preapproved" solicitation. This basic information
- includes interest rate (APR), annual fee, and grace period.
- Disclosures must also be provided before annual renewal if the card
- issuer imposes an annual fee.
-
- Source: {Consumer Rights} pamphlet, mentioned in part 1 of this FAQ
- list. If you have a problem, the agency to complain to depends on
- the nature of the card issuer (Federal Savings Bank, National Bank,
- credit union, etc.); see the pamphlet.
-
-
- section 3. Lists of good cards
- ==============================
-
- This FAQ list can't tell you which card is best for you. Your spending
- patterns and needs are different from others', and credit-card terms are
- constantly changing. What this section can and will do is give you a
- few simple steps to find the information on your own. Remember to
- evaluate any card offer against the criteria in section 2, "Good deals,
- bad deals."
-
- Q301. Where are lists of the best cards?
-
- No one card is best for everyone. Are you looking for a card with
- no annual fee? low interest rate? long grace period? Do you want
- a secured card? Lists are published in several places.
-
- - {Barron's}, an investment weekly, lists low-rate cards, no-fee
- cards, and the biggest card issuers near the back of the "Market
- Laboratory" section of every issue.
-
- - {Money} Magazine's "Money Scorecard" also carries a brief list of
- inexpensive credit cards, with phone numbers of the issuers.
-
- - {The Wall Street Journal} publishes a monthly list, lately on
- Friday of the first week of every month. Look in the index on
- page C1 for "credit card rates." (The most recent publication
- dates were Monday, 4 May, and Friday, 3 Apr.)
-
- Many libraries have back issues of some or all of these periodicals.
- Be sure to ask at the reference desk if you don't see them on
- display.
-
- Q302. I don't want to look up magazines. Isn't there an easier way?
-
- First, don't post a request to the net. You may get some replies,
- but typically they'll be for banks out of your area and will be
- missing important information. Besides, those repeated requests are
- just what this FAQ list is supposed to prevent, and you wouldn't
- want me to look foolish, would you? :-)
-
- Fortunately, you can get a list by mail. Here are your choices,
- from the May 1990 {Consumer Reports}. (Prices may possibly have
- changed since then.)
-
- - Bankcard Holders of America, 560 Herndon Parkway suite 120,
- Herndon VA 22070: send $1.50 for list of 50 "Fair Deal" banks
- (low interest rate on cards) or $1.50 for a separate list of
- no-fee cards. Phone number: (800) 553-8025 or (703) 481-1110.
-
- - RAM Research, P O Box 1700, Frederick MD 21701: send $5.00 for
- 500-bank "RAM Research Bankcard List" (updated monthly).
-
- - Consumer Credit Card Rating Service, P O Box 5219, Santa Monica CA
- 90405: send $12.00 for "Credit Card Locator," over 100 no-fee
- cards, 200 more with fees under $15, and interest rates on cards
- from 1000 banks.
-
- Disclaimer: I have not actually ordered from RAM or CCCRS myself.
- If you have any corrections from experience (not hearsay), please
- email me at adams@spss.com.
-
- Q303. I understand why low rates or no annual fees are important. Why
- would I care about which banks issue the most cards?
-
- A bank that issues lots of cards may be less choosy than a bank with
- fewer customers. If you are expecting problems getting credit, the
- larger bank might be more willing to accept you.
-
- Q304. Okay, I know that First Mumble Bank of Fubar has a card I want to
- apply for. How do I get in touch?
-
- First, don't post a request to the net for their phone number. This
- costs hundreds or thousands of dollars and wastes lots of people's
- time. You may get the number you want, but it takes a few days, but
- you surely will get some nasty email.
-
- Quoting from the FAQ in another group: The network is NOT a free
- resource, although it may look like that to some people. It is far
- better to spend a few minutes of your own time researching an answer
- rather than broadcast your laziness and/or ineptitude to the net.
-
- Try (800) 555-1212 (it's free) to find if the bank maintains an 800
- number; many do. If not, look at the area-code map in the front of
- your phone book to find the area code of the city where the bank is
- located (or you can call 411, or the Operator); dial 1, the area code,
- and 555-1212. Then call the bank and ask for an application.
- Alternatively, larger public libraries have banking directories and
- can probably give you the information at the reference desk or by
-
- phone.
-
- (continued in part 3)
- --
- The opinions expressed above are those of the author and not SPSS, Inc.
- -------------------
- adams@spss.com Phone: (312) 329-3522
- Steve Adams "Space-age cybernomad" Fax: (312) 329-3558
- Xref: bloom-picayune.mit.edu misc.consumers:61099 news.answers:4274
- Path: bloom-picayune.mit.edu!enterpoop.mit.edu!spool.mu.edu!olivea!pagesat!spssig.spss.com!adams
- From: adams@spss.com (Steve Adams)
- Newsgroups: misc.consumers,news.answers
- Subject: misc.consumers FAQ on credit part 3 of 4
- Keywords: credit-cards chargebacks consumer-rights
- Message-ID: <1992Nov30.140439.796@spss.com>
- Date: 30 Nov 92 14:04:39 GMT
- Expires: Thu, 14 Jan 1993 14:04:40 GMT
- References: <1992Nov30.140238.631@spss.com>
- Sender: news@spss.com (Net News Admin)
- Followup-To: misc.consumers
- Distribution: usa
- Organization: SPSS Inc.
- Lines: 813
- Approved: news-answers-request@MIT.Edu
- Supersedes: <1992Oct23.174816.8456@spss.com>
-
- Archive-name: consumer-credit-faq/part3
- Last-modified: 21 Oct 1992
-
-
- This FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions) list should be a repository of the
- canonical "best" answers. If you know a better answer or a change that
- improves an answer, please tell me! (Use email, please. Traffic in
- this group is high, and I might miss a relevant posted article.)
-
- Steve Adams, SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA
- adams@spss.com
-
- Because this list is quite long, I am posting it in four parts:
- part 1 of 4: detailed contents and introduction
- part 2 of 4: credit cards
- part 3 of 4: credit cards continued (this file)
- part 4 of 4: credit reports
- Please read the disclaimers, acknowledgements, and general information
- in part 1. (The most important disclaimer is that I am not a lawyer and
- this file is not to be construed as legal advice.)
-
-
- Some helpful free pamphlets are available from the FRB. You can write
- to Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Publications
- Services, MS-138, Washington DC 20551 for these among others:
-
- - How to File a Consumer Credit Complaint
- - Consumer Handbook to Credit Protection Laws
-
- The phone number is (202) 452-3244 in case they accept phone orders.
-
- See part 1 of this FAQ list to obtain a catalog of FRB publications,
- including many on home-equity loans and other home mortgages.
-
-
- section 4. When you buy with a credit card
- ==========================================
-
- Murphy's Law has free play in credit matters. Here are some common
- problems and how to avoid them (if you can) or resolve them (if you
- must).
-
- Q401. Is it better to pay by check or by credit card, as a rule?
-
- In general, it's better to use a credit card. When you pay by
- credit card, the U.S. Fair Credit Billing Act gives you a lot of
- protections (see section 5, "Billing errors and overcharges").
- These safeguards don't apply if you pay by check or by debit card.
-
- However, be aware that credit-card debt is about the most expensive
- legal kind there is. With banks paying as low as 3% on savings (as
- of January 1992) but charging 19% or more on credit-card balances,
- it makes sense never to carry a balance past your grace period.
-
- Household budgeting is beyond the scope of this FAQ list. But
- always bear in mind that if you're paying by check because your
- credit cards are maxed out, you may well be overextended and may
- want to think about deferring major purchases. Even if your cards
- aren't maxed out, if you're carrying a balance from month to month
- you are paying dearly for the privilege.
-
- Q402. When I make a purchase, can they ask for my address or phone
- number?
-
- This is a complicated question. There are two possible sources of
- an answer: Federal and state law, and the policies of the
- card-issuing organization.
-
- Law: There is no Federal law on the subject. According to Bankcard
- Holders of America, the laws of CA, DE, GA, MD, MN, NJ, NV, and NY
- prohibit recording personal information in connection with
- credit-card transactions. Note the word "recording": strictly
- interpreted, this means they can ask you to show a driver's license
- but can't write anything down from it.
-
- Policy: According to letters from
-
- Director of Public Affairs and
- Visa USA Inc. MasterCard International
- P.O. Box 8999 888 Seventh Avenue
- San Francisco, CA 94128-8999 New York, NY 10106
-
- merchants are not allowed to refuse a sale made by Visa or
- MasterCard solely because the customer refuses to provide additional
- personal information. According to Bankcard Holders of America, the
- same is true when you use your American Express card, but not when
- you use Discover.
-
- If merchants have "sufficient" reason to suspect you are not the
- authorized card holder, they may ask for further ID. This exception
- rarely comes up in real life, and even if it does they must not
- write the information on the Amex, Visa, or MC charge slip.
-
- Q403. If it's against the rules, why do merchants insist on address or
- phone number?
-
- Don't rule out ignorance: many merchants don't know the rules.
- They may think (wrongly) that getting extra information from you
- will protect them somehow. The truth is that if they follow the
- procedures of the credit-card company, they will get paid, period.
-
- On the other hand, some merchants are deliberately flouting the
- rules and depending on you to acquiesce. Why? Because they can
- sell your address or phone number, or add you to their in-house list
- of sales prospects.
-
- Don't accept the old wheeze about "in case there's a problem." If
- the merchant follows proper procedures at the time of sale, there
- won't be. If you leave your card behind they can send it to the the
- card issuer, who will return it to you.
-
- Q404. What should I do when asked for personal information I don't want
- to give?
-
- See also "Is there any official document" and "Where should I report
- merchants who break the rules?" later in this section.
-
- If you don't see what all the fuss is about, please skip this Q.
- Note the key words, "information that I don't want to give."
-
- The most effective response is to ignore the request. When they
- say, "I need your signature and phone," simply sign in the proper
- place and hand them the charge slip without your phone number.
- Don't comment on the request in any way. More often than not, they
- won't follow up.
-
- If they do notice that you didn't put down the personal information,
- and ask you again for it, simply say quietly "I don't give that
- out." Almost all the time, the clerk writes down something like
- "refused" and that's the end of it.
-
- If they still insist, you have to decide how important it is to you
- to make a point. If you don't much care, give them what they want
- so you can get back home.
-
- If (like me) you're a privacy fanatic, you can do one of several
- things. (1) Point out that Visa and MasterCard rules don't allow
- them to require this information and wait to see what they do.
- Typically the clerk calls the manager to "authorize" the sale, which
- she does right away. (2) Or you can say "Fine: if you can't make
- the sale without this information, give me a credit slip and keep
- the merchandise." (Since the sale has already gone into the register
- they probably won't call your bluff. They've never called mine. If
- they do, get a written credit slip unless you're sure that the
- transaction has not already been processed electronically.) (3) Or
- you can make up a phone number. Please use one beginning with 555
- so that some innocent person doesn't get sales calls. (4) Or, if
- you happen to know the number of the store it's always a nice touch
- to give them that.
-
- In all this, be firm but pleasant and quiet. Don't raise your
- voice, but if this is important to you then don't let yourself be
- bullied either. After all, this is America and you can almost
- always get equivalent merchandise from another store.
-
- Q405. I tried to charge a $10 item but the merchant pointed to a sign
- "minimum charge $20." Is this valid?
-
- Never for Visa and MasterCard; generally not for American Express.
- Discover explicitly allows the merchant to set a minimum purchase
- amount, according to email received by the previous editor.
-
- MC and Visa rules provide that a merchant may not require any
- minimum purchase amount. This is the merchant's agreement with Visa
- or MasterCard; it is not a Federal law. (On the other hand, if you
- insist on charging a 79-cent ball point pen, I hope you get four
- flat tires on the way home.)
-
- According to Bankcard Holders of America, if a merchant takes
- American Express and also Visa or MC, Amex doesn't let the merchant
- impose a minimum purchase on Amex users because that would
- discriminate against them. Merchants who take Amex but neither Visa
- nor MC may impose minimum charges but Amex officially discourages
- the practice.
-
- Q406. Can the merchant charge credit-card users more than cash customers
- for the same item?
-
- In a word, maybe. In a few more words, probably, if the merchant
- goes about it the right way.
-
- The Federal Truth-in-Lending Act prohibited surcharges on credit-
- card purchases until 1984; since then, there has been no Federal law
- on that subject. (Other provisions of the law are still in force.)
- The states of CA, CO, CT, FL, KS, MA, ME, NY, OK, and TX have laws
- against surcharges, according to Bankcard Holders of America.
-
- Discover allows surcharges on credit-card purchases, except in the
- above states. Visa and MasterCard prohibit them. American Express
- discourages them in general, and specifically prohibits them by
- merchants that also take MasterCard or Visa because Amex doesn't
- allow merchants to discriminate against it.
-
- There is a loophole: merchants are allowed to give cash discounts.
- This means in practice that they can't charge you more than the
- labeled price if you pay by credit card, but they can charge you
- less if you pay cash. Some companies announce (usually in tiny
- print in the catalog) that all prices "reflect cash discount" of x%
- so credit-card users must pay x% more than the stated price; this
- may be legal but it certainly violates the spirit of the law or the
- regulations. I don't know about the "service fee" charged credit-
- card users for things like ordering tickets over the phone, but
- they're certainly not allowed to charge you a higher price in person
- than if you pay cash.
-
- The other loophole, according to Bankcard Holders of America (BHA),
- is this. Certain government agencies are by law not allowed to pay
- "discount fees," which are the processing fee the bank charges
- merchants for handling credit-card slips. Since the banks won't
- handle these for free, if your state lets you pay license fees by
- credit card you may well have to pay a surcharge for the privilege.
- However, BHA says that there are no exceptions for retail merchants.
-
- Q407. I made a hotel reservation, and guaranteed it with my credit card.
- When I showed up, the hotel denied my reservation. Have I any
- recourse?
-